Homophobia is on the rise in society, and scientists say the dislike of lesbians and gays is linked to low intelligence. Just like racism
If we were to be specific with regard to the growing hate against LGBTQ, for example, the annual increase in hate crimes in London in 2019/2020 has reached 55%. Then in France, crimes directly against lesbians and gays more than tripled in 2020. No wonder, then, that the message that homophobia is now resonating again in the media is closely linked to how intellectually equipped (or rather unequipped) people are.
There have been several studies in the past (and we mean the relatively recent past) pointing to a possible link between IQ and homophobic attitudes. But they were conducted in the US and not infrequently on not very large samples. It was not until a study by researchers at the Univesity of Queensland confirmed for the first time in a population outside the States that intolerance of lesbians and gays was related to low intelligence. And the same has been shown for racism.
The dumber, the more hateful
The research involved just under 12,000 Australians, and the researchers also analysed data from the Australian Household, Income and Work Dynamics Survey, which asked respondents questions with the intention of assessing cognitive ability. Similarly, data from a 2015 survey that looked at, among other things, respondents' attitudes towards equal rights was also considered. Specifically, attitudes towards, for example, the statement "homosexual couples should have the same rights as heterosexual couples" were assessed on a scale from 1 (strongly disagree) to 7 (strongly agree).
So, if we were to very briefly summarize the result of this research, basically the researchers found that the dumber people are, the more likely they are to also have prejudices against same-sex couples. "There are well-known correlations between low cognitive ability and the promotion of captive attitudes," the authors then write, among other things. The link in question was particularly strong when verbal ability was assessed, but the association was equally strong when controlling for variables such as education, economic or social status.
However, a study conducted in the UK in 2012 had a similar outcome. According to it, lower intelligence in childhood was a "predictor" of higher levels of racism in adulthood. "Our results suggest that cognitive ability plays a crucial, albeit neglected, role in prejudice," the authors summarised.
In this context, a direct comparison with the so-called symbolic racism theory is offered. The latter works on the basis that whites feel that blacks violate classical values and also make illegitimate demands for a change in the racial status quo. Thus, in the case of gay/les persons, this lens can be used to say that the heterosexual majority feels that different sexual orientations violate social values and also makes demands for changes in the organization of society (e.g. through registered partnerships, recognition of same-sex marriages, but also the creation of so-called rainbow families).
Instinctive resistance?
But of course, the topic of why so many people literally can't stand lesbians and gays has also been the focus of scholars in the past - in this case, the deeper one. But the results of their research have been mostly theoretical speculation, or a mass of empirical data, but without being embedded in a broader theoretical framework. In some cases, the various theories even pointed to the personal prejudices of the author rather than to the reasons for negative reactions to LGBTQ people by the general population. For example, William James in the 1890s suggested that the repulsion to the idea of same-sex intimacy was instinctive and affected more men than women. Tolerance of difference was therefore, in his view, learned and 'aversion' to it natural. There would still have been nothing so shocking about such a view in 1890, however, if James had not also been the author of the hypothesis that for most men there is some possibility of attraction to persons of the same sex...
But a lot has changed since 1890 (though certainly not as much as could potentially change in the direction of acceptance of LGBTQ people). Today, many parts of the world have succeeded in promoting equality regardless of gender, as well as sexual orientation; on the other hand, quite common stereotypes persist in society - according to them, gay people are promiscuous, lonely, insecure, and even, according to some opinions, might sexually molest children. However, even lesbians do not have a "clean slate" in this optic - they are described as aggressive and also hostile towards men. And in fact, they are thus attributed masculine qualities, whereas gay men are attributed feminine qualities by many, such as sensitivity, empathy, etc. (both of which are of course considered bad).
What does all this imply? While much has indeed changed, people have certainly not wised up. However, a certain light at the end of the tunnel is the fact that everything can be worked on. And as the researchers also summarize, the only possible way to truly come to acceptance of all without distinction is through education. It's just a pity that, especially in recent times, we don't seem to be getting enough of it.